Banner by SRoni
Maxima Culpa
by Aadler
Copyright February 2014
Disclaimer: Characters from Buffy the Vampire Slayer are property of
Joss Whedon, Mutant Enemy, Kuzui Enterprises, Sandollar Television, the WB, and UPN.
The air was close in the confessional, the familiar smells of aged wood and lemon Pledge and the faintest background hint of incense. (Or maybe that was imagination, even in the main church incense was used rarely these days, surely it wouldnt linger in this out-of-the-way corner.) Mary Claires knees protested as she knelt at the partitioning screen; not from the position itself, she was supple with the careless flexibility of the young, but they ached from cuts and a bad scrape, and one had been wrenched worse than shed been free enough to notice at the time. She drew a steadying breath, waiting for the first words from beyond the screen, because it would make a profound difference who was there In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, she heard from the other side, and the air went out of her in a whoosh of relief that stabbed her with embarrassment an instant later. Father Nolan, thank God. Father Kinsolving was good-hearted but gruff and vinegary, serving out his retirement years in this last posting in Sunnydale; and the rector, Father Heywood, was so cheerfully, blandly forgiving that you sometimes wondered if he took the concept of sin seriously. Hed be gone soon, because rectors seldom stayed beyond the two-year mark at St. John of the Cross. The associate rector, however, Father Nolan, had been a constant, reassuring presence for nearly seven, and while his recommendations and observations could be discomforting, they were never inaccurate. And there was no way of doubting that he believed, deeply and earnestly and with every moment of his attention.
That totality of conviction had sometimes made her impatient, and occasionally resentful, because she herself had no such certainty. Right now, though, she needed it. That, and so much more.
Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. She said the old words, instead of following any of the newer, trendier versions. It has been She had to stop and think; she couldnt remember, she wasnt even sure when was the last time she had come to Mass. at least six months since my last confession. Thats, I guess thats one of the things I have to count as sins, I havent been attending Mass, havent honored the days of obligation She drew another breath; she had never liked this part, never, but what was the point of confession if you hid anything? I also, um, I lied to my mother, I told her I needed extra money for student activity fees at college, but I really spent it on an iPod. (Lying and dishonoring her mother, she thought with self-scathing irony. Bonus points for the combination.) And, its been over for awhile now but I, since my last confession I was in a, a sexual relationship with one of my classmates. And, and we used contraception even though I know thats also a sin. (Another bonus combo. Really, why not have an affair with a married man and rack up some major points?) And that wasnt
How many times did you engage in non-marital intercourse? Father Nolan gently interrupted. And was contraception part of every such instance?
It wasnt salacious interest, she knew, or even intended to rub her nose in her failings. If you were going to confess, Father Nolan would help you to clarify your sins, to type and extent. Though it had taken her some time to reach that conclusion, she now saw it as a kind of respect. Maybe maybe ten, maybe fifteen times, she admitted. We were intimate for a little less than a month. And the, the first time was spontaneous but after that he always used condoms. And drugs arent really big at UC-Sunnydale, not like at some places, but I was at a party where someone passed a joint and I took a puff even though I didnt really want to, just so I wouldnt be the, the odd one out
She stopped. She hadnt been avoiding this, shed been building up. You were supposed to address the worst sins first, but when time allowed she preferred to confess in small-to-larger-to-largest order (though the joint was an afterthought, shed thrown that in because shed suddenly remembered) She wasnt trying to dodge, this was why she was here, but now that it was time to say the words, they seemed to stick in her throat.
Yes, my child? Steady, encouraging. Father Nolan always knew when and what to say, no mind-reader could have done it better. He knew somehow that there was more, she knew he knew, and that was all it took to free her.
I think I think people are going to die because of me, Father. She clenched her hands into fists, the torn nails biting into her palms. In fact, its practically a guarantee. And I dont know how I can live with being responsible for those deaths.
* * *
The air is foul in the alley, an awful amalgamation of spilled garbage, old grease from the hole-in-the-wall burger joint out front, urine and vomit from occasional drunks and terror, and pain, and a desperate disbelief crumbling under the siege of onrushing reality. Her knees sting and throb, she was flung to the alley floor with a force she couldnt have anticipated even if shed been able to resist, but the greatest pain is in her shoulder, twisted to the point of dislocation, and her throat, where those horrible teeth were just beginning to close before the unexpected interruption.
What we need here, her momentary savior is saying calmly, is a cost-benefit analysis.
Really? The single word is followed by a sharp laugh, nasty and somehow sneering. What I need is a bunch of my buddies to help me take down the Slayer, or maybe a machine gun so I can do it myself. A sharp jerk of the twisted arm draws a strangled whimper from Mary Claire, and her captor goes on sardonically. Dont have any of those, though, and I know your rep so I know I wont walk away from here still unbreathing. That means I just have to get what kicks I can in the time I have left and, right now, the biggest kick Ive got is the look on your face when I rip her throat open and guzzle her down like a party keg.
You dont want to do that. The tone is still casual, not even a warning note. Its matter-of-fact, as if she were watching someone change a tire, and offering advice. And not that there had ever been any doubt its Buffy Summers voice. Mary Claire hasnt seen her since the Prom (she decided to skip the graduation ceremony, and duly got her diploma by mail a month later), but she isnt about to forget that effortless, unassailable confidence. Its almost enough to make her hope but the savage grip on her arm, the other hand wound through her hair to keep her neck exposed, serves an icy reminder as to the limits of hope.
Oh, I do want to do this. Jerris smile can be heard even if Mary Claire cant see her face. Ive wanted to since I first saw her tonight, and if this is the last fun Ill ever have, I intend to make it count.
Mary Claire knows Jerri knew her, from the freshman orientation tour at UCSunD and was surprised to run into her at the little out-of-the-way bar, Jerri had vanished from her dorm and been a no-show in all her classes and been written off as just one more whod found the college transition too overwhelming. But then, tonight, she was back again and greeting Mary Claire happily and eagerly, and the two of them fell effortlessly into a rollicking girls-night-out. Jerri was different somehow, assured and amused and centered, and if the suggestive smiles and subtle, constant innuendoes made Mary Claire suspect her old friend had developed new appetites well, she wasnt interested, but it was kind of flattering to be regarded with desire from an unexpected direction. She could enjoy that without being caught up in it, she knew where to draw the line
Except Jerris new appetite isnt what Mary Claire thought, and shes clearly not taking No for an answer.
It doesnt have to be the last, Buffy is saying. Thats my point here. I dont want her dead. You dont want to be dust. You do want to kill her, and I do want to dust you, but neither one of us can get what she wants without losing something shed rather keep. Its a classic lose-lose scenario. Only, we can lose big, or we can lose not-so-big.
Nope, dont see it, Jerri shoots back. Youre not letting me go, I know that, and Im not letting her go just so you can kill me without feeling guilty. Well, I want you to feel guilty. I want you to be hearing her screams in your nightmares for the rest of your life. She laughs gaily. Hey, everybody wants to make a mark on the world, right?
Look, just listen for a minute, okay? Now Buffy sounds a little impatient, a little annoyed. Nothing like the mortal terror Mary Claire is feeling, but at least shes involved, a change from the nonchalant detachment shes shown so far. Ive been doing this for awhile, and its not the first time Ive run into this particular situation, and we can deal. A minor alteration in the voice, what might come with a tilt of the head. Yeah, Id rather she stay alive, but Ive seen a lot of death by now and, sorry, my nightmares are still the standard naked-in-class stuff.
Now, what I mean by cost-benefit analysis? I worked that out a long time ago. Basically, you let her go, I let you go. She gets to live another day, you get to die some other night except, if you take the deal and honor it, you might even survive the next time I catch you at dinner. Because youll have shown that your word is good, and because youll spread the news amongst the other evil undead that Ill keep my word, too.
You called it right: the way it would normally play, both of you would die in the next few minutes. If we can reach an agreement, though, you can both go on living or, in your case, unliving but still peppy.
So: can we negotiate here?
* * *
It was a delicate question, but it had to be asked, because the answer would reveal just how well she could explain, or if it was hopeless. Father, how much do you know about about the way things are in Sunnydale?
On the other side of the partition, Father Nolan sighed. I know much more than most. When you hear people confess the things they wouldnt dare admit to anyone else, you get a picture very different from surface appearance. Another sigh, and then he went on more briskly. I know what happened at high school graduation wasnt a gas explosion. I know not to invite anyone into my home unless theyre standing in clear daylight. I know that a lot of people take holy water from this church, and most of them keep coming back for more. I know that some graves call for extra prayers, consecrations that arent exactly public knowledge. The odds are, my child, that if you know of anything unusual in Sunnydale, I know it, too, or something very similar. Does that help you?
It did. Somehow, Mary Claire had been sure Father Nolan would know the truth here (even though she hadnt, not really, not deep down, until last night). So if I tell you something that sounds crazy, youll know that maybe it isnt. Right?
At the very least Ill know that, in this town, crazy and true arent mutually exclusive, he assured her. Does that set your mind at rest?
It helps a lot. Then Mary Claire began describing the events in the alley. Since this was an actual, formal confession, she had to admit her initial suspicion that Jerri might be coming on to her, and that she had done nothing immediate to discourage it even if shed never intended to let that go anywhere. (Yes, knowingly exciting lust in someone was an offense. If this was going to mean anything, she had to be honest.) Even though her self-revelation was heartfelt and genuine, another part of herself recognized that she was stalling, putting off the moment when she would have to reveal the deepest shame. Yet the very effort of evasion and delay served to paint a more detailed picture, so she kept on, making it more and more complex and vivid, until at last she faltered to a halt.
Your friend was gone, Father Nolan observed as her silence lengthened. What you saw was a demon wearing her body, using her appearance and mannerisms to seek prey. And the other girl, her exploits are also familiar to me. You neednt be concerned that I wont believe, or understand.
Any such concern had been settled some time back. Mary Claire drew a breath and said, What Ive told you so far, that was just groundwork. So you could see what I mean when I tell you what what came next.
Yes.
What came next.
* * *
Still keeping that excruciating pressure on Mary Claires arm, and still maintaining that sadistic gaiety, Jerri says, It doesnt matter what kind of story you spin, I wont believe you. Youre the Slayer. You dont bargain with me and my kind, you just dont. I may have risen at night, but it wasnt last night. Id have to be a total idiot to believe any promise you made, and Im not.
You havent thought it through, Buffy replies, still matter-of-fact, and for the first time Mary Claire feels a spark of anger at her would-be rescuer. Even though this business is all about her, shes being utterly ignored here, by the heroine as well as the villainess: theyre negotiating about her, but both of them are talking past her, as if she were a puppy or a pound of hamburger. Mary Claires position has shifted slightly, she can see Buffy now, and Like I said before, the other girl continues, Ive had time to go all over situations like this. And She pauses, for a moment. I used to watch a lot of cheap TV, she says in seeming total non sequitur. B-movies and old black-and-white historical dramas, stuff like that, and after awhile I realized this one scene kept popping up. Some bad guy double-crosses somebody, and his victim or henchman or somebody goes, But you gave your word!, and Bad Guy du jour sneers, My word? To a ? She stops, shrugs. From there on, you can fill in your own blank. To a Jew, heretic, infidel, slave, rebel, peasant, barbarian basically, not-really-people-so-the-rules-dont-apply-here. She leans forward, and her tone sharpens. But they do. Doesnt matter who youre giving it to, either your word is good or it isnt. If it isnt, if you break a promise like that, people learn youre a lying weasel and then youre S.O.L. if you ever need to make a deal. Me, Ive been doing this business for nearly seven years now, I cant afford that kind of short-term thinking. If you and I reach an agreement, Ill follow out on my part of it just because I cant afford to be known as someone who wont honor a bargain.
For the first time, the strain on Mary Claires shoulder seems to slacken perhaps the tiniest bit. You know, there was something a while back, Jerri muses. I mean, nothing direct, more I knew a guy who knew a guy but according to that, the guy forced you into the deal.
Maybe thats the way he actually saw it, Buffy says, shrugging again. What matters is, you heard about it. Like I said, I need the word to get around that Ill let you go if you let your She motions toward Mary Claire. your catch go. And, I dont know if you remember this part, it isnt just for now. Play it right, keep your promise, and theres a future payout for you.
Yeah, you said something about that, Jerri agrees. Wasnt sure I understood it. Not saying I believe you, but tell me how thats supposed to work.
Buffy nods brisk satisfaction. Okay. I only do this once in a while, but it does keep coming up, so I worked it into a system. She fiddles with something on her wrist, makes a tossing motion. Catch.
Mary Claire cant see what it is too small, and the streetlamps dont really penetrate this far into the alley but Jerri releases her arm to snatch the unknown object from the air, still maintaining the iron clutch in Mary Claires hair. So whats this? Jerri asks. We exchanging love tokens now?
One of the charms from my bracelet, Buffy explains. Something personal, something Ill recognize. Put a string through it and wear it around your neck. I run into you again when youve got somebody ready to bite into, our little haggling session will go a lot easier: youll know by then that I will keep a promise, and you pull that out and show it to me because I may have forgotten, I really do go through a lot of you bloodsuckers and Ill know your word is solid. She smiles suddenly, hard and dangerous. Only, heres the good part, the little bonus I use to seal the deal: if I catch you out on your own, no helpless victim to use as a bargaining chip? you yell Pax, haul out the charm, and Ill let you hand it over that time, that one time, cant redeem it but the once for a free walk.
Through the hand clenched in her hair, Mary Claire feels Jerri go completely still. Youre not serious.
You dont think so? Ill say it again, Ive gone through this before, and Ive learned that I usually cant make a straight trade. Throw in something to sweeten the deal, though, and all of a sudden you carnivore types start thinking about how this could really work out for you. Remember I said we were in a lose-lose here? Take the offer and you win, I win A nod toward Mary Claire. and she wins.
And I get to use your little trinket as a get-out-of-dusting card, Jerri says. Trying to sound skeptical, even contemptuous, but Mary Claire can hear the sudden raw hope surging underneath the controlled words.
Once, Buffy replies sharply. Only the one time, Im not about to write a blank check, but that one time is better than the pointy end of a stake, which is the only thing youll get from me otherwise. And I get a live civilian, and you tell your blood-gulping buddies about the kind of deal they can make, which means more people wind up alive this way, we all come out ahead.
No, Mary Claire says.
It startles them both; shes made no sound other than a whimper since Buffys initial appearance. Jerri jerks at her hair. Quiet, you, the grown-ups are talking.
No, Mary Claire says again. The first time, she could barely manage a croak, but this one sounds like it might actually have come from a human throat. She swallows, moistens her lips, then goes on. If you let her go, she says to Buffy, shell kill other people. You know it. You cant let that happen. I cant be part of something like that.
This yank is hard enough to pop neck muscles, wrenching a hard cry of pain from Mary Claire. I said be quiet, Jerri snarls. Nobody gives a damn what you want or dont want. Open your mouth again and
Remember, youve got nothing to trade if you kill her, Buffy points out. To Mary Claire she adds, Shes right, though. It really isnt your decision, so if you can just stay still and let us reach an agreement here
No! Mary Claire shouts, and throws all her strength into sudden total effort, trying to push to her feet. No success, shes instantly slammed back down to the alley floor with an impact that drives the air from her lungs, and Jerris heel is on her throat, weight poised to crush her windpipe. She lies back, momentarily exhausted with pain and lack of breath. Buffy, she sees, hasnt moved.
How about that? Jerri laughs. The blood-bag actually wants me to chow down on her? Boy, talk about too dumb to live
Mary Claire can hear it in her former friends voice: the gloating, the greedy hunger for more and worse, and through all her despair she feels a flare of scorn for a creature so bent on perpetrating pain and death that its ready to throw away its own survival just to dispense a little more. That shallowness, that one-dimensionality, is a weakness, the only one at which Mary Claire can take aim. Her hand is bleeding, it fell on a broken beer bottle, and her fingers close imperceptibly on the neck. Jerri is wearing a short skirt, Mary Claire can slash at the bare legs and the vampire wont be able to stop itself from murderous reaction
all she has to do is slash
all she has to do
all she
She lies without moving, tensed for action but unable to make herself commit. Still up to you, Buffy is saying casually to Jerri. Youve got my best offer, so whats it gonna be? Kill her and go poof half a second later, or take the deal and die another day?
Jerri stands tense, too, uncertain but wanting to believe. Ive got your word? she asks.
You have my word, Buffy says firmly. Remember, I want the news to get around that Im willing to make this trade. For me to get what I want, my word has to be good.
Mary Claire feels the moment stretch out, and by now shes too torn to even know what to hope for. Then, Ill take your deal, Jerri says, and slowly moves her foot from Mary Claires throat. Now what?
And Buffy takes a step back: away from Jerri, away from Mary Claire. Now you walk away, she tells Jerri. You hold onto my token, and I get this one to a hospital.
It still isnt too late for Mary Claire to act. She does nothing, lying where she is while a wave of blackness sweeps over her. See you around, she hears Jerri call jeeringly from the end of the alley, with a sharp little snickering sound at the end, and then quiet falls around them and Buffy is kneeling next to her.
You were determined not to make that easy, werent you? she asks archly. She pulls Mary Claire up to a sitting position, turns her head to inspect the exposed neck. Okay, good, she didnt rip through anything important. She broke the skin, though, you should probably get shotgun antibiotics cause the tanless crowd is not big on dental hygiene. So, ready to get up now? On three: one, two
Buffy hauls her upright, but Mary Claire pushes the other girl away as soon as shes on her feet. Why did you let her go? she demands, hoarse and tremulous. Why did you let her go? You should have taken her down, no matter what it cost. Instead, shell kill and kill and kill, and itll be because of me. WHY DID YOU LET HER GO?
Buffys eyes are steady, and for all the gentleness of her hands as she was helping Mary Claire up, there is no sympathy in that voice. I do this for a living, she tells Mary Claire evenly. Its a judgment call and, nothing personal, Im the only one here qualified to make those. Go through a few thousand of these things yourself, or garrote a Hakklusch with your own pantyhose, and then you can start telling me what to do.
You should have killed her, Mary Claire whispers again, strength and will draining from her as abruptly as if Jerri had opened up her throat after all.
Dont worry about her, Buffy answers cheerfully. Any vamp willing to make a deal like that is too cocky to zip out of Sunnydale on the night express and if they stay here, Ill run into em again sooner or later, count on it.
And then youll just let her go again, Mary Claire thinks with something very like grief. She doesnt say it, though, because a few seconds later she simply passes out, like some swooning damsel in a silent movie.
When she looks back on it later, shell recognize that she would be embarrassed about that, if there werent so many other reasons for so much greater shame.
* * *
Did the hospital confirm there was no permanent damage? Father Nolan asked, soft-voiced with concern.
Yes, Mary Claire told him. Buffy advised me to say it was a random mugging and when they looked at her, she just smiled, and they didnt even call in the police. Apparently Father Nolan wasnt the only one who knew some of the truth about Buffy Summers.
Good, he said. Youve been very, very lucky. I hope you can appreciate that.
I wasnt lucky, Mary Claire protested. I made a choice. I chose to let other people die instead of me. It was right there, I could have forced it, I could have, but instead I just I just
You lived, Father Nolan said, completing the sentence she couldnt. You lived, and I cant mourn that. You were in a harrowing situation, for which you had no preparation, and you did the best you could, and you lived. There is cause for regret here, but not self-condemnation.
It wasnt my best, she corrected him again, the pain inside her making her tone harsh. I should have done more. I knew what to do, but I just lay there like a coward.
Father Nolan sighed, and for several seconds there was silence. What I am about to say is not merely for your comfort, he began at last. You brought this into the confessional, so my first obligation is to the good of your soul. I must help you reconcile your sins and in this thing that causes you the most pain, there is no sin. If you had sacrificed yourself to save others as you were prepared to do, as you tried to do that would have been heroism. If you had sacrificed others to save yourself, that would have been cowardice and more besides. To do as you did, to bring yourself to the point of giving your own life, but then find yourself unable to take the crucial step that would have made it happen that was simply human, and your efforts till then trend more toward the heroic.
Besides that are some, well, some less definite issues. Your death then would have been an immediate fact, dreadful and irrevocable. The deaths that may come about because you were She could hear the momentary smile in his voice. not quite completely heroic, are contingent, theoretical. They may happen, or may not. If you had died to save others, and I knew of it, I would honor you and grieve. Instead, I rejoice, and see no cause to chastise you for not having done better.
You have been delivered, my child. As one whose responsibility is to speak with Christs voice on earth, my advice is that you give thanks and praise for your deliverance, with full gratitude and no reservation.
Mary Claire shook her head, though of course that wouldnt be visible through the screen. I I still feel She stopped, swallowed. Then she asked, What do I do now?
The silence was longer this time. This is my own opinion, he said finally. Not a matter of doctrine. But I believe you should leave Sunnydale, make a life for yourself elsewhere. This town is not a good place to be.
Leave Sunnydale. It felt like exile and escape at the same time. Do you give this advice to many people? she found herself asking.
Another sigh. Not many. Not often. Too few would understand, or believe, and His voice firmed. The forces of Hell filter into this town, but here also God has sent a warrior of Heaven. I can see that His plan is at work here, even if I dont come close to understanding it. Perhaps I should try to persuade more to leave; I wonder often if I am failing in this regard. But in your case I feel more confidence. I say again, this is my own advice rather than a moral obligation, but I believe you should go. I hope you will give it serious consideration.
Yes, Father, Mary Claire said.
Good. Now, it sounds as if you have reached the end of your confession. Was there any more?
She shook her head. No, Father.
Then I will assign your penance. For deceiving your mother, three Our Fathers, to represent the respect our earthly parents are due. For non-marital intercourse and the use of contraception, ten Hail Marys, while you meditate on the proper living of a virtuous life. For the marijuana use and your absences at Mass, five Glory Bes, and ask that the Holy Spirit support you in meeting your obligations and overcoming your weaknesses.
Finally, not as penance but in thanksgiving for your deliverance, I ask you to recite an entire Rosary, and dedicate it to the welfare and souls of all who live in Sunnydale. Including me. Can you remember all that?
Yes, Father. Uh, do you mean a full Rosary? All four sets of mysteries?
You can if you wish. But, if you do only one, I would suggest the Sorrowful Mysteries. Theres more than ample sorrow here, I think. His voice had gone somber on that last, but it was back to normal as he added, You may say your Act of Contrition now.
Mary Claire folded her hands and began the recitation: O my God, I am heartily sorry for having offended Thee, and I detest all my sins, because I dread the loss of Heaven and the pain of Hell
* * *
The unconscious girl is an awkward burden, not because of her weight the Slayer could maintain a light jog while carrying a motorcycle but simply because limp bodies are cumbersome. All the same, Buffy gets her into a fairly steady position and begins the walk to Sunnydale General, already thinking ahead to the other things she has to take care of tonight.
At the end of the alley she stops and bends down, balancing her load with one hand while the other sifts through the small heap of dust at the beginning of the sidewalk, and finally finds the metal charm from her bracelet. The thrown stake caught the she-vamp right at the end of her parting taunt, she probably never knew till the instant the hardened wooden point lanced through her heart.
No, the Slayer cant be known to break her word which means there cant ever be any surviving witness when she does. Buffy took a chance here, saw the injured girls eyes roll back and put the stake into the air in the same moment. A chance, but shes used to making split-second decisions and confident in her skills and judgment.
Too bad she cant tell the girl that her life hasnt been bought at the cost of anyone elses, but she might get vamped herself someday, and then there would be one who knew, and thats not a risk worth taking. Its a shame, she seems like the type wholl agonize over something like that but at the end of the day, you can only hurt if youre still alive.
She straightens again, readjusts her load, and continues on her way to the hospital.
* * *
Mary Claire had completed her penance, and wound up reciting all four sets of the Rosary after all: the Joyful Mysteries, the Sorrowful, the Luminous, and the Glorious. She remained kneeling at the pew closest to the altar, though, weeping for the faceless unknowns whose lives would pay for hers, while she whispered over and over the words from the communal confession at Mass: Through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault
– end –
[ A supplementary drabble for this story can be seen HERE. ]